Thursday, April 3, 2014


I've talked about commenting on blogs before, but today, this is different. Today I'm going to talk about why I use intensedebate and not any other free commenting program. I'm not going into the whole intensedebate vs. disqus vs. Google+ comments + other commenting programs. I'm going to talk about why this works for me, and how I made it work for me.

Why I love intensedebate...

It notifies the original commenter via email when I reply to their comment/s
For me, this is important because blogging is about discussing, and it is somehow a forum to exchange ideas, and get to know the blogger and the reader more. I have found this to work on my last Goldie's musings post, How has book blogging changed you?, and I was able to meet new bloggers (Hello, Ella, Monica, Amir, Mel, and Anna!) and go back and forth a couple of times. We were having a discussion! Finally!

But some comment programs don't notify the reader if I replied. And I also hate this when I comment on other blogs, because I do want to go back and continue the discussion. It's easier for me to know when someone has replied, and I just have to click the link on my email notification.

I can tweak its appearance...and it's got smileys!
Granted, I haven't really tweaked it much because I'm fine with the basic look. As for the smileys, if you've seen my previous commenting system, I have some pretty nifty smileys with wine glasses (I used that particular emoticon smiley, I was wondering if my readers thought I'm a drunk). I miss them, but they're a small sacrifice to pay. However, intensedebate has a few, though basic, smileys through their Plugins, and I use them once in a while, too.

It enables me, a Blogspot blog, to have Commentluv
I think I mentioned this to another blogger before, that I envy Wordpress users for having Commentluv. Why? Because it makes it easier for me to visit the blog of my reader who left a lovely comment! I don't have to go through the trouble of finding their URL, or clicking on their profile to be brought to their website, or latest post. Easy peasy.

My initial Googling of Commentluv for Blogger didn't yield favorable results, but I tried again this year. And voila, there is a way for us Blogspot bloggers!

How?
1) Sign up for intensedebate/log in to your account. Add your blog to your account.
2) Click Plugins. Look for Commentluv, then click Activate.
3) Download your blog's code through the Template tab, upload to intensedebate, wait for their instructions.

And there you have it!

However, my installation of Commentluv hasn't been smooth-sailing. I know some of my readers complained that their comments were lost. I'm so sorry, and believe me, I'm sad that they're gone, but I don't think there's a way for me to retrieve them because Blogger overrode the intensedebate comments.

If you're like me, where intensedebate suddenly disappears, to be overtaken by Blogger, here's a possible fix (which worked for me):

1) Go to Template tab on Blogger
2) Click the gear button under Mobile template.
3) Choose mobile template --> Custom. Save.

I haven't had any trouble with my comments since then. And visiting other bloggers and paying back the commenting love has never been easier! But as always, I'm still open to suggestions. I like software and tinkering with it.

How about you, what do you use for your commenting system, and how has it made your blogging life easier?


03 Apr 2014

Comments (18)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I use Disqus and love it for the most part. I'm with you on the notifications thing. That was a HUGE seller for me. And it's really helped the blog and developing relationships with bloggers and readers I think and getting them to come back in. I love you can add photos to the comments as well. So much fun some days.

I am jealous of the commentluv. That's my only complaint with Disqus is that I don't always know someone's a blogger. I always try to visit people back who visit me but sometimes there's just no way if they don't leave a link or I catch on to their name.

But overall I'm happy with my choice. Glad you were able to make yours work for you and got your comment luv plugin :)
My recent post Midnight Pursuits (Killer Instincts #4) by Elle Kennedy
1 reply · active 573 weeks ago
I know. I tried Disqus before, but I was really looking for Commentluv, so I went with it.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who tried hunting around. And I totally realized the benefits of having a good commenting system!
That's why I love Wordpress. I can just install a plugin that notifies a commenter that I replied to their comment. It's very useful, and I do agree that Intense Debate is very useful ;)
My recent post Book Review 152 : Faking Normal by Courtney C. Stevens
1 reply · active 573 weeks ago
I know. :( That's one of the things I love about WP. I actually tried Wordpress and couldn't make sixes and sevens out of it, and I've been using Blogspot for over 12 years so I'm still here :)
My recent post Review: Romancing the Duke [Castles Ever After, book 1]
Nice! Oh, and thanks for this post. I think I forgot to set mine to do this! LOL
My recent post No Ordinary Mistress by Robyn DeHart | Book Review
1 reply · active 573 weeks ago
I use IntenseDebate too! :D

I didn't understand wordpress. Free on there is pretty bland. -_-
My recent post Blogging + Real Life: How Do You Balance Both? ~ Part 1
3 replies · active 470 weeks ago
Me too. I have a few 'group' accounts for Wordpress and I felt so lost :( I feel like I can tweak Blogger more, too, or maybe that's because I know it more than Wordpress.
My recent post Review: Romancing the Duke [Castles Ever After, book 1]
Oh, don't worry. You're not alone. I'm completely lost on Wordpress.
My recent post Blog Tour: Wicked Hunger - Excerpt + Giveaway
Yes, Wordpress not so simple
Is that me up there? Lol hi Goldie! Anyways, I've been thinking on trying commentluv on my blog too, but right now I'm still good with the default blogger comment setting. :)
My recent post Review: Into The Still Blue by Veronica Rossi
7 replies · active 570 weeks ago
Haha what do you mean, Ella? :) Commentluv has done wonders for my blog commenting system. Haha I sound like a PR person for Commentluv! I'm not :D
My recent post Review: The Mephisto Club [Rizzoli & Isles, book 6]
Will it erase my old comments on my blog? This is what bothers me. I like that it makes it easier for me to go to the commenter's latest post, that's why I'm thinking about using that too. :)
My recent post Review: Into The Still Blue by Veronica Rossi
Depends! If you choose for Intensedebate to take over all your posts, your old comments will disappear, I think. But you can choose to only have Intensedebate installed on your new and future posts :)
My recent post Review: The Mephisto Club [Rizzoli & Isles, book 6]
Oooh, okay. Maybe I'll give this a try, thanks for the info Goldie :D
My recent post Review: Into The Still Blue by Veronica Rossi
Your "promotion" worked lol I installed commentluv on my blog. :p
My recent post Review: Into The Still Blue by Veronica Rossi

Post a new comment

Comments by